Shelley versus Society

The age in which Shelley grew up was one of significant contradictions and tensions with regard to the ardent optimism of earlier Romantic writing. He himself was full of ardour and had the spark of a progressive and revolutionary outlook. He admits himself in his Preface to Prometheus Unbound:

‘I have what a Scottish philosopher characteristically terms ‘’a passion for reforming the world’’.

Percy Bysshe Shelley, born in 1792, read both Godwin and Paine when they were no longer so immediately and dangerously controversial but the ideas promulgated by both men were still deemed novel, seditious and heretical. The French Revolution, such a testing ground for ideas and ideals, remained the dominating event on Shelley’s lifetime and, despite a gathering scepticism based on disappointments and experience, he remained very much a fellow promoter of the ideals of Godwin.

© D.F. Macrae, Alasdir. Percy Bysshe Shelley. Selected Poetry and Prose.

architecture-316712_1280

Shelley’s unconventional life and uncompromising idealism, combined with his strong disapproving voice, made him an authoritative and much-denigrated figure during his life and afterward. He was a strong advocate for social justice for the ‘lower classes’ and he became a fighter for the rights of all living creatures that he saw being treated unjustly. One of the ways he used to fight against injustice and oppression was poetry.  However, he seemed not to fit into the society at all and the feeling of solitude that he had during his life, is shown into almost all of his poetics works, but mainly in his poem Alastor, or the Spirit of Solitude.

© http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Percy_Bysshe_Shelley

Throughout his adult life, Shelley detested organized religion. He saw the gods of religion as created by societies, as reflections of the worst aspects of humankind:

‘’Barbarous and uncivilized nations have uniformly adored under various names a god of which themselves were the model: revengeful, bloodthirsty, grovelling and capricious. The idol of a save is a demon that delights in carnage. The steam of slaughter, the dissonance of groans, the flames of a desolated land are the offerings which he deems acceptable, and his innumerable votaries throughout the world have made it a point of duty to worship him to his taste. The Phoenicians, the Druids, and the Mexicans have immolated hundreds at the shrines of their divinity, and the high and holy name of God has been in all ages the watchword of the most unsparing massacres, the sanction of the most atrocious perfidies’’.

This denunciation by Theosophus in a Refutation of Deism voices Shelley’s own view, and modern societies have not shown much improvement. On the other hand, the poet did not deny the probable existence of a force, a spirit, beyond or behind the material universe; but such a force may not be comprehended or characterized by human beings. In a rather Nietzschean affirmation, Shelley even suggests that we can become God:

‘’Whosoever is no deceiver or destroyer of his fellow men- no liar, no flatterer, no murderer- may walk among his species, deriving from the communion with all which they contain of beautiful or majestic, some intercourse with the Universal God. Whoever has maintained with his own heart the strictest correspondence of confidence, who dares to examine and to estimate every imagination which suggests itself to his mind, who is that which he designs to become, and only aspires to that which the divinity of his own nature shall consider and approve- he has already seen the God. We live and move and think, but we are not the creators of our own origin and existence; we are not the arbiters of every notion of our own complicated nature; we are not the masters of our own imaginations and moods of mental being. There is a Power by which we are surrounded… This Power is God’’

(Essay on Christianity, undated)

The most sustained attack on religion in his poetry is in sections VI and VII of Queen Mab.

It has often been claimed that Shelley had an inadequate theory of evil. Certainly, evidence can be found in the earlier works to support the view that he saw evil as an illusion or delusion or mistake which could be rectified by rational though and that he supported Godwin’s belief in the perfectibility of mankind. In her ‘Note on Prometheus Unbound’ (written 1839), Mary claims:

‘The prominent feature of Shelley’s theory of the destiny of the human species was that evil is not inherent in the system of the creation, but an accident that might be expelled… mankind had only to will that there should be no evil, and there would be one. That man could be perfectionized as to be able to expel evil from his own nature, and from the greater part of the creation, was the cardinal point of his system’.

Corroboration for this claim can be found in the words of Julian and Maddalo.

Although he died young, he was in no way an inexperienced or ignorant man. He had seen the ravages of war, he followed with interest the public events of his time, he had seen poverty and brutality and prejudice, and he had experienced love and happiness. As he grew older, the world came to appear more tragically paradoxical, and in a letter to Mary in August 1821, he confesses that ‘Good far more than evil impulses – love far more than hatred- has been to me, except as you has been its object, the source of all sorts of mischief’. The climax of the Furies’ assault on Prometheus comes in these lines:

The good want power, but to weep barren tears;

The powerful goodness want: worse need for them.

The wise want love; and those who love want wisdom;

And all the best things are thus confused to ill.

Many are strong and rich, – and would be just –

But live among their suffering fellow men

As if none felt: they know not what they do.

(Act I, II. 625-631)

No writer of his time denounced corruption, inequality, hypocrisy and cruelty more fiercely than Shelley and, in the short term, he felt that much could be improved immediately if there was a will for change. He analysed a deepening class antagonism and he had to face the probability that real reform could happen only through violent revolution:

‘’This is the age of war and the oppressed against the oppressors, and every one of those ringleaders of the privileged gangs of murderers and swindlers, called Sovereigns, look to each other for aid against the common enemy, and suspend their mutual jealousies in the presence of a mightier fear… but a new race has arisen throughout Europe, nursed in the abhorrence to produce fresh generations to accomplish that destiny which tyrants foresee and dread’’.

© D.F. Macrae, Alasdir. Percy Bysshe Shelley. Selected Poetry and Prose.

One of Shelley’s most well know poems, Ozymandias (1819), is an attack on tyranny and power, something he frequently returns to in other works like Prometheus Unbound. Related political issues include attacks on aristocracy, law, militarism, poverty, labour and money. He had an extraordinary acute sense of the inequalities promoted by a social system based on financial competition. Particular relevant here are his Notes to the long poem Queen Mab. Published in 1812, this work was used throughout the 19th century by working-class educational organizations like the Chartists, often without their being aware of its author identity. The Notes from a series of explosively radical essays, in which, for example, he attacks wealth as ‘a power usurped by the few, to compel the many to labour for their benefit’. Shelley’s awareness of the economic motor generating social injustice is a crucial part of his political analysis, as in his major political essay ‘A Philosophical View of Reform’ (1819), where he denounces merchants and bankers as ‘a ser of pelting wretches’. During this productive year, Shelley wrote his famous poem Ode to the West Wind, completed what is classed by many as his major work, Prometheus Unbound, along with his most powerful  political poem The Mask of Anarchy, some great short poems, the underrated play The Cenci, as well as the political essay already mention. But then 1819 was a remarkable year in many ways, being a time of great ferment in Britain, a factor directly related to Shelley’s output. So in order to understand the nature of works he wrote we need to set them in a wider context.

Yet by the Autumn of 1819, Shelley seems had succumbed to the general atmosphere of hopelessness sufficiently to indulge his own form of melancholy in his ‘Ode to the West Wind’. Keats’ question is his ode ‘To Autumn’ sets the tone for this period and for the second generation of the Romantic Poets more generally: Where are the songs of spring?  After the ardent certainties of Blake and early Wordsworth, what is noticeable about the second generation of Romantic writers is their scepticism. A number of significant poems, for example, end with questions rather than answers. As we will read in ‘Ode to the West Wind’, the poem also finishes with a question. The answer lies in a combination of factors, literary and personal, historical and radical.

© Woodcock, Bruce. The selected Poetry and Prose of Shelley